Caller ID Not Working For Some Contacts

I've been having an issue with Caller ID not showing up for some of my contacts when they call - particularly ones that have a country code prefix in the address book.

Does anyone know how I can make the phone recognize that contact is calling me? I had a Nexus 5 prior to my Samsung Note 5 and never has this issue.

If anyone can help it'd be much appreciated.

Thanks a ton!